Here are some of the twitter responses from the Faithful.
@49erholics dont make me pick. It's like picking which of my children I love more.
— SH*T 49ERS FANS SAY (@49ersFansSay) February 13, 2014
@49erholics whitner less difficult to replace
— TrevRX (@SFTEAMS) February 14, 2014
— Focused (@Mr_Mike_O) February 14, 2014
— Anthony Leyton (@AnthonyLeyt0n) February 13, 2014
@49erholics Boldin for sure. Whitner is replaceable.
— SF49ers68 (@SF49ers68) February 13, 2014
@49erholics there is no OR…take care of both.!
— Anthony Trejo (@Trejo50) February 13, 2014
— Matt Cowlishaw (@MattCowlis) February 13, 2014
The overwhelming response was that out of Boldin and Whitner, Boldin was the player that if they could choose only one should be re-signed.
Thanks for everyones responses. We hope to post another question like this in the future.